You've got fifteen browser tabs open about story structure. Your notebook is filled with character sketches. You know exactly how your protagonist's childhood trauma shaped their fear of commitment. But your actual manuscript? Still sitting at Chapter 3, where it's been languishing for six months.
If this sounds familiar, you're not alone. Many writers struggle to finish stories not because they lack ideas or skill, but because they run out of steam somewhere in the messy middle. The solution might lie in an unexpected place: Brandon Sanderson's Promises, Progress, Payoff framework, traditionally used for plotting, but incredibly powerful when repurposed as a completion accountability system.
What is Promises, Progress, Payoff?
Brandon Sanderson developed this framework to help writers create satisfying story arcs. Here's the basic concept:
- Promise: You establish reader expectations (introducing a mystery, conflict, or question)
- Progress: You develop and complicate that promise throughout the story
- Payoff: You deliver a satisfying resolution
But here's the twist: this same framework can transform how you approach the actual writing process, not just story structure. I call this adaptation The Forward-Chain Writing Method, and it's specifically designed to build the discipline and endurance needed to reach "The End."
The Forward-Chain Writing Method Explained
Instead of applying Promises, Progress, Payoff to your plot, you apply it to your writing sessions and manuscript milestones. This creates a self-reinforcing system that builds momentum rather than relying on willpower alone.
Here's how it works:
Promise (to yourself): Before each writing session, identify one specific story question or scene outcome you'll answer/complete. Write it down. Make it concrete and finishable within your available time.
Progress (visible and tracked): During your session, work exclusively toward that promise. Track your progress in a way you can see—word count, scenes completed, plot points resolved. The key is making forward movement visible and undeniable.
Payoff (immediate and earned): When you fulfill your promise, give yourself a meaningful reward AND immediately make the next promise for your following session. This creates a chain of completed commitments.
The magic happens when you repeat this cycle. Each completed promise proves you can finish things, which rebuilds the discipline muscles that atrophy when we abandon stories mid-draft.
How to Implement Forward-Chain Writing
Let me show you exactly how this works in practice.
Step 1: Chunk Your Story Into Promisable Units
Break your remaining manuscript into specific, completable questions or outcomes. Don't write "finish Chapter 7." Instead, write:
- "Reveal why Marcus is lying about the accident"
- "Show the confrontation between Sarah and her mother"
- "Resolve whether the crew discovers the sabotage"
Each unit should be answerable in one to three writing sessions maximum. If it's bigger, break it down further.
Step 2: Make Session Promises, Not Word Count Goals
Before sitting down to write, select ONE unit from your list and state your promise explicitly: "Today I will draft the scene where Marcus confesses about the accident."
This is critically different from "I'll write 1,000 words today." Word count goals ignore the actual story progress. You can write 1,000 meandering words and feel accomplished while your story hasn't moved forward an inch. Promise-based goals force you to advance the narrative.
Step 3: Track Your Chain Visibly
Create a visual tracker—a simple checklist, a chain of paper clips, a spreadsheet, whatever speaks to you. Each time you complete a promise, mark it done.
The visual accumulation of completed promises creates powerful psychological momentum. You're not just "working on your novel." You're building an unbroken chain of kept commitments. Breaking that chain becomes increasingly difficult as it grows longer.
Step 4: The Immediate Next Promise
Here's the secret sauce: the moment you complete a promise, immediately identify your next one before you leave your writing session. Write it down. Be specific.
This eliminates the "what do I write next?" paralysis that kills so many writing sessions before they begin. You always know your next target.
A Real-World Example
Let me walk you through how this saved my friend Rachel's abandoned fantasy novel.
Rachel had written 40,000 words of a 90,000-word story but hadn't touched it in four months. Her problem wasn't ideas—she knew exactly what happened next. She just couldn't make herself open the document.
We implemented Forward-Chain Writing. First, she listed her next ten story units:
1. The queen refuses Kira's request for help
2. Kira discovers the hidden passage in the library
3. Confrontation with Daemon about his betrayal
4. The ritual that reveals Daemon's true motivation
(And so on...)
For her first session, she promised: "Today I will write the scene where the queen refuses Kira's request."
She didn't promise to write it well. She didn't promise 2,000 words. Just to draft that specific story moment.
She wrote 847 words and finished the scene. She marked it complete on her tracker and immediately wrote down her next promise: "Tomorrow I will draft Kira discovering the hidden passage."
After two weeks, Rachel had completed fourteen promises and written 18,000 words. More importantly, her story had progressed through crucial plot points. The forward momentum rekindled her excitement for the project.
Two months later, she typed "The End."
Why This Works When Willpower Doesn't
The Forward-Chain Method succeeds because it addresses the root causes of abandonment:
It makes progress concrete. "Working on my novel" feels endless. Completing twelve specific promises feels achievable and measurable.
It builds discipline incrementally. Each kept promise strengthens your ability to keep the next one. Discipline becomes a skill you practice, not a personality trait you either have or don't.
It creates positive reinforcement loops. Completing promises generates momentum and satisfaction, which fuels motivation for the next session. You're not grinding through on willpower—you're riding genuine forward energy.
It eliminates the infinity problem. A whole novel feels overwhelming. One scene outcome feels doable. String together enough doable promises, and you've written a novel.
Your First Steps
Ready to try this? Here's what to do today:
1. Open your abandoned or stalling manuscript
2. Identify where your story currently stands
3. Write down the next 5-10 specific story questions or outcomes that need to happen
4. Choose ONE for your next writing session
5. State your promise explicitly and write it down
6. Complete it
7. Make your next promise immediately
The beauty of Forward-Chain Writing is that you're no longer trying to summon the discipline to "finish your novel." You're simply keeping a promise to complete one specific story moment. Then another. Then another.
Before you realize it, those completed promises will have carried you to the finish line.