You're halfway through your manuscript when it hits you: exhaustion. Not physical tiredness, but a deep creative fatigue that makes every scene feel like pushing a boulder uphill. You know where the story needs to go, but getting there feels impossible. The problem isn't that you don't know what happens next—it's that writing what happens next feels dull, mechanical, and utterly draining.
Here's the counterintuitive solution: you're probably writing too much of what your characters are actually thinking and feeling. And there's a specific technique that can transform this exhausting directness into engaging, energizing prose that practically writes itself.
The Iceberg Dialogue Method: Your Endurance Solution
The Iceberg Dialogue Method is a conversation-writing technique adapted from Hemingway's iceberg theory and modern subtext training for actors. The principle is simple: in any conversation, only 20% of what characters truly mean should appear on the page as direct dialogue or action. The remaining 80% stays submerged—implied, suggested, or completely hidden from both other characters and readers.
Why does this help you finish stories? Because it transforms every conversation from a one-dimensional information exchange into a puzzle you're solving. Instead of grinding through "character A tells character B the thing, then they discuss the thing," you're engaging in a creative challenge that keeps your brain alert and interested.
The Three-Layer Setup
Before writing any scene with dialogue, spend five minutes (no more) creating three layers:
Surface Layer (20%): What the characters actually say and do—the visible tip of the iceberg.
Hidden Agenda Layer (40%): What each character really wants from this conversation but won't directly state.
Wound Layer (40%): The emotional injury or fear driving their hidden agenda, which they themselves might not fully recognize.
Let's say you're writing a scene where a daughter visits her mother in the hospital. You're exhausted, you know they need to "reconcile," and the thought of writing another heartfelt conversation makes you want to close your laptop.
Instead, try this:
- Surface: They discuss the hospital food, the flowers someone sent, whether the TV remote works
- Hidden Agenda: The daughter wants her mother to apologize for missing her wedding; the mother wants to be forgiven without having to admit wrongdoing
- Wound: The daughter fears she's unlovable; the mother fears appearing weak
Now write the scene using only the surface layer, but with the other layers informing every word choice, pause, and gesture.
The Practical Application: A Before and After
Before (Direct/Exhausting):
> "Mom, I need to talk about what happened at my wedding," Sarah said.
>
> Her mother sighed. "I know I hurt you by not coming. I was scared."
>
> "Scared of what?" Sarah asked.
>
> "Of seeing you not need me anymore."
This works, but writing scene after scene like this is soul-crushing. It's too neat, too resolved, too much like a therapy session. You know exactly what everyone means at all times, which means there's no discovery, no surprise—just mechanical transcription of emotions you've already planned.
After (Iceberg Method/Energizing):
> "The flowers are nice," Sarah said, adjusting the vase on the windowsill so it blocked her mother's view of the parking lot.
>
> "Your aunt sent them." Her mother's fingers picked at the blanket edge. "She has excellent taste."
>
> "Unlike some people."
>
> "The remote's broken. I've been watching whatever's on."
>
> Sarah moved it six inches farther from her mother's reach. "Sometimes we don't get to choose."
See the difference? Nothing is stated directly, yet everything is present. The subtext—blocking the view, the pointed "unlike some people," the remote as a power metaphor—creates tension and meaning without exhausting explanation. Writing this version is actually fun because you're implying, suggesting, and layering rather than laboriously spelling everything out.
Why This Builds Endurance
The Iceberg Dialogue Method solves the finishing problem in three specific ways:
1. It creates micro-challenges: Each conversation becomes a craft puzzle—how can I show this without saying it?—which engages your problem-solving brain instead of just your endurance.
2. It prevents resolution fatigue: When characters never quite say what they mean, conversations stay tense and unresolved, generating natural forward momentum. You're not constantly wrapping up emotional threads; you're complicating them.
3. It makes revision easier: Subtext-heavy dialogue requires less fixing in revision because it's already doing multiple jobs—advancing plot, revealing character, creating tension. You're less likely to abandon a draft when you know the bones are strong.
Implementing the Method Scene-by-Scene
When you sit down to write and feel that familiar dread about the next conversation:
1. Set a timer for 5 minutes and write out your three layers on a notecard
2. Physically hide the hidden agenda and wound layers—put the notecard face-down
3. Write only surface dialogue and action with the feeling of those hidden layers in your body
4. Add no explanatory thoughts or internal monologue during the first draft
5. Trust the reader to sense what's underneath
The magic happens when you realize you're excited to write the scene—not because you're explaining something important, but because you're concealing something important. That shift from exposition to implication changes writing from an endurance test to a creative game.
The Finish Line Advantage
Stories die in the middle not because writers lack discipline, but because the writing itself becomes monotonous. The Iceberg Dialogue Method keeps you engaged by making every conversation a craft exercise in restraint and suggestion.
Your characters are always saying less than they mean. Your readers are always sensing more than they're told. And you—you're finally having fun again, which means you'll actually reach the ending.
That's not a discipline problem solved. That's a joy problem solved.